Что не положено быку ↑
metanymous в посте Metapractice (оригинал в ЖЖ)
| Комментируем: Отзыв на интервью Роберта ДИЛТСА | |||||
| 1. Комментируем: Отзыв на интервью Роберта ДИЛТСА | immergent | ||||
--Я воспринимаю эти разборки про "универсальность" чисто как какое-то клоунское представление.
--Вы посмотрите предпосылки появления их совместной заметки. Сначала на французском НЛП-сайте было выложено переведённое на французский интервью с Дилтсом. Оно привлекло внимание Гриндера и вызвало достаточно жёсткий (как по мне, даже эмоциональный) критический разбор некоторых утверждений
Эх, так и не нашел от какого числа года эти разборки.
A Review of an interview by Robert DILTS By John GRINDER, co-creator of Neuro-Linguistic Programming
http://www.repere-pnl.com/site/a_review_of_an_interview_by_robert_dilts_par_john_grinder_29032006-234.html
Ну, вот смотрим.
I am in possession of the translation of an interview recently published by the french school PNL REPERE in which Robert DILTS makes a number of points which have stimulated my interest and to which I wish to respond. Over the years, I have noted, sometimes with amusement, sometimes with annoyance and most frequently a mixture of both, the re-writing of the history of NLP. Typically, this is done by people who were not present at the origins and initial discoveries of the principle patterns of NLP and have no idea about the events that they pretend to comment on. Such behavior may be due to ignorance or with fraudulent intent: it is often difficult to determine which. However when someone as well-known and who is as well-positioned to know something about what actually occurred as Mr. DILTS is attempts to re-write NLP history, the amusement I might otherwise experience quickly dissipates. I have no question about Mr. DILTS' intelligence - thus ignorance is ruled out. Some of his statements in this interview do raise questions about other aspects of his behavior and the intentions behind them.
Т.е. Дилтсу историю пересматривать нельзя. Но Джону Г. - можно. Хозяин - барин.